Can’t handle different file names.

[navid-zamani]

I stopped calling my kernel files “vmlinuz” a long time ago, because it doesn’t fit modern systems and formats.
And eclean-kernel just removed ALL my kernels! If the config files hadn’t been saved somewhere else too, they’d be gone and I would have had to re-install from backups before rebooting, or been left with a broken system. :/

My layout is as follows: In /boot, there are symlinks
.config -> /boot/.config-$currentVersion
.config.stable -> /boot/.config-$lastVersion
System.map -> /boot/System.map-$currentVersion
System.map.stable -> /boot/System.map-$lastVersion
kernel -> /boot/kernel-$currentVersion
kernel.stable -> /boot/kernel-$lastVersion

E.g.
currentVersion=5.13.10-zen1.0
lastVersion=5.13.4-zen1.0

eclean-kernel deleted every System.map-* and every kernel-* and then all /etc/src/linux-* directories too, including the .config files therein.

Looking at its, frankly, gigantic amount of source code for such a simple program, I cannot even locate where to alter what it looks for to determine which kernels are still in use. It seems to all be much too generic code. So I’m even more surprised it failed for my case. (Did it fail because of the symlinks?)

So can you please enable people to specify how they named their stuff inside /boot?
Because like this, eclean-kernel is not only useless for all but “I don’t care, just do it the standard way” cases… when the whole point of Gentoo is that you care and customize… but it also can be out-performed by a 5-line bash script. (Or a Haskell one-liner, albeit in write-only code ;)

[thesamesam]

I stopped calling my kernel files “vmlinuz” a long time ago, because it doesn’t fit modern systems and formats.
And eclean-kernel just removed ALL my kernels! If the config files hadn’t been saved somewhere else too, they’d be gone and I would have had to re-install from backups before rebooting, or been left with a broken system. :/

My layout is as follows: In /boot, there are symlinks
.config -> /boot/.config-$currentVersion
.config.stable -> /boot/.config-$lastVersion
System.map -> /boot/System.map-$currentVersion
System.map.stable -> /boot/System.map-$lastVersion
kernel -> /boot/kernel-$currentVersion
kernel.stable -> /boot/kernel-$lastVersion

E.g.
currentVersion=5.13.10-zen1.0
lastVersion=5.13.4-zen1.0

eclean-kernel deleted every System.map-* and every kernel-* and then all /etc/src/linux-* directories too, including the .config files therein.

I would use --pretend in future, but it's of course unfortunate.

Looking at its, frankly, gigantic amount of source code for such a simple program, I cannot even locate where to alter what it looks for to determine which kernels are still in use. It seems to all be much too generic code. So I’m even more surprised it failed for my case. (Did it fail because of the symlinks?)

Nobody is making you use this, to be fair.

So can you please enable people to specify how they named their stuff inside /boot?
Because like this, eclean-kernel is not only useless for all but “I don’t care, just do it the standard way” cases… when the whole point of Gentoo is that you care and customize… but it also can be out-performed by a 5-line bash script. (Or a Haskell one-liner, albeit in write-only code ;)

Sure, Gentoo might have a lot of use for customisation, but that doesn't mean one particular upstream is obligated to make their software do what you want. It's worth being a little bit more polite when making feature requests IMO.

[jstrieter]

The Gentoo distribution kernel package sys-kernel/gentoo-kernel has started calling their kernel "kernel-" instead of vmlinuz as of 6.6 so either this issue should be taken seriously or the eclean-kernel package deprecated and it's use discouraged on the Kernel/Removal page - or at least a warning added.

Edit: added output of --pretend.

% sudo eclean-kernel -p

Legend:
[-] file being removed
[+] file being kept (used by other kernels)

These are the kernels which would be removed:

• modules-only 6.6.21-gentoo-dist: vmlinuz does not exist
  [-] /lib/modules/6.6.21-gentoo-dist/../../../src/linux-6.6.21-gentoo-dist
  [-] /lib/modules/6.6.21-gentoo-dist
  kernel-install will be called to perform prerm tasks.
  Bootloader grub2 config will be updated.

[yaaarg32]

Ran into this same issue today when trying to automate some of my tasks.

eclean-kernel -n 4 -p
eclean-kernel has met the following issue:

SystemError('No vmlinuz found. This seems ridiculous, aborting.')

If you believe that the mentioned issue is a bug, please report it
to https://github.com/mgorny/eclean-kernel/issues. If possible,
please attach the output of 'eclean-kernel --list-kernels' and your
regular eclean-kernel call with additional '--debug' argument.

I see a long list of "modules-only":
eclean-kernel --list-kernels
modules-only 6.9.6-gentoo-x86_64 [None]

• modules: /lib/modules/6.9.6-gentoo-x86_64
• build: /usr/src/linux-6.9.6-gentoo
• last modified: 2024-06-27 09:18:57
  modules-only 6.9.5-gentoo-x86_64 [None]
• modules: /lib/modules/6.9.5-gentoo-x86_64
• build: /usr/src/linux-6.9.5-gentoo
• last modified: 2024-06-21 21:03:33
  ...
  etc.

Debug:
DEBUG:root:Sorter: <ecleankernel.sort.VersionSort object at 0x7fd8e9a335f0>
DEBUG:root:Layout: <ecleankernel.layout.blspec.BlSpecLayout object at 0x7fd8e97a2870>
DEBUG:root:Bootloader failed: <class 'ecleankernel.bootloader.lilo.LILO'>
DEBUG:root:/boot/grub/grub.cfg found
DEBUG:root:Bootloader: <ecleankernel.bootloader.grub2.GRUB2 object at 0x7fd8e97a2810>
DEBUG:root:in get_removal_list()
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/lib/python-exec/python3.12/eclean-kernel", line 8, in
sys.exit(setuptools_main())
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/lib/python3.12/site-packages/ecleankernel/main.py", line 391, in setuptools_main
sys.exit(main(sys.argv[1:]))
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/lib/python3.12/site-packages/ecleankernel/main.py", line 251, in main
removals = get_removal_list(
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/lib/python3.12/site-packages/ecleankernel/process.py", line 81, in get_removal_list
raise SystemError(
SystemError: No vmlinuz found. This seems ridiculous, aborting.

[Nowa-Ammerlaan]

The Gentoo distribution kernel package sys-kernel/gentoo-kernel has started calling their kernel "kernel-" instead of vmlinuz as of 6.6 so either this issue should be taken seriously

I think this has been resolved already some time ago. Does the latest version work for you?